
When an employer believes an employee may have committed misconduct, it will usually need to investigate and may then start a disciplinary procedure. Getting the process right matters. If an employer fails to follow a fair procedure, it may face a grievance and, if the employee is dismissed, a claim for unfair dismissal in the employment tribunal.
One of the first decisions an employer often has to make is whether to suspend the employee while the investigation takes place. This article looks at the basic requirements of a fair disciplinary process and then focuses on suspension, where Acas guidance and case law both urge caution.
The basics of a fair disciplinary process
The Acas Code of Practice on Disciplinary and Grievance Procedures sets out the minimum standards that employers are expected to follow. In summary, an employer should:
- investigate the allegations without unreasonable delay
- tell the employee in writing what is alleged and provide the evidence
- hold a meeting so the employee can respond and put their side of the story
- allow the employee to be accompanied by a colleague or a trade union representative at a disciplinary hearing
- decide on any action fairly and consistently, and confirm it in writing
- give the employee the right to appeal
A tribunal can increase compensation by up to 25% if an employer unreasonably fails to follow the Code. Our guide to how HR investigations should be conducted covers the investigation stage in more detail, and our article on common mistakes employers make in disciplinary proceedings highlights where things often go wrong.
Employers should also note that unfair dismissal protection is changing. From 1 January 2027, the qualifying period for most unfair dismissal claims falls from two years to six months, and the statutory cap on compensation is removed, so a fair process will matter for many more employees.
Is suspension a neutral act?
Many employers used to assume that suspension carried little legal risk, provided the employee continued to receive full pay and benefits and the contract allowed it. That view is no longer safe.
Every employment contract contains an implied term of mutual trust and confidence. In Gogay v Hertfordshire County Council (2000), the Court of Appeal found that suspending an employee without reasonable and proper cause breached that term.
In London Borough of Lambeth v Agoreyo [2019] EWCA Civ 322, the Court of Appeal clarified that there is no test of whether suspension was “necessary”. The question is whether the employer had reasonable and proper cause, and the court said that labelling suspension as a “neutral act” was not helpful.
The practical point is that an unjustified or prolonged suspension can amount to a serious breach of contract. That could allow the employee to resign and claim constructive dismissal. Our article on compensation for constructive dismissal explains what that can mean.
What the Acas guidance says
In September 2022, Acas published updated guidance on suspending employees during an investigation. It makes clear that suspension should not be automatic and should only be used where it is reasonably necessary, for example to protect the investigation, other staff, the business or the employee themselves.
The guidance encourages employers to:
- consider what is known so far and the risks of not suspending
- look at alternatives first, such as changing the employee’s duties, shifts, location or system access
- think about the employee’s wellbeing and mental health, as suspension can be very stressful
- explain clearly that suspension is not a disciplinary sanction and does not mean any decision has been made
- keep the employee on full pay and benefits, unless the contract clearly says otherwise
- name a contact person, keep in touch and signpost support
- keep the suspension as short as possible and review it regularly
Care is also needed where two employees are involved. Moving or suspending someone who has raised a complaint could amount to victimisation.
A practical approach for employers
Suspension remains a legitimate option, particularly where there is a genuine risk to witnesses, evidence or safety. What matters is that the decision is considered and proportionate.
Employers should record why they decided to suspend, which alternatives they considered and why those were rejected, and how they have supported the employee. A written record like this can show a tribunal that the decision was not made hastily. It is also wise to review your disciplinary and suspension policies so that they reflect current guidance.
If the investigation also involves a complaint from another employee, our tips for managing workplace grievances may help. Employees who are facing an investigation or suspension can find out more about our support with investigations, disciplinaries, grievances and appeals, and employers can read about our employment law advice for employers.
To discuss a suspension or disciplinary issue, book a free 30-minute consultation or call us on 0141 471 9166.
Get in touch
You are one step closer to solving it
We are here to help. Relax, you are in good hands. Book a free 30-minute consultation and an employment solicitor will explain your options in plain English, with no obligation to continue.






