
When money is tight, employers naturally look for ways to cut costs, and redundancy is often the first option considered. But compulsory redundancies are hard on morale, and they can mean losing skilled, experienced people you will need again when trading improves. If you believe a downturn is temporary, or a change in strategy has not yet had time to pay off, it is worth looking at the alternatives first.
Considering alternatives is also part of a fair redundancy process. Employers are expected to look at ways of avoiding or reducing compulsory redundancies, and to consult staff about them. Here are ten options to consider.
Ten alternatives to compulsory redundancy
1. Limit external recruitment
Where possible, avoid replacing people who leave. Consider whether the work can be shared among existing staff, and advertise vacancies internally first so that employees at risk can apply.
2. Reduce or stop overtime
Cutting overtime can save money quickly if the business does not need it. Explain to staff that this is a way of protecting jobs. Take care where overtime is guaranteed in the contract, as removing it will need the employee’s agreement, and remember that some employees will have come to rely on the extra pay.
3. Redeploy and retrain
If one part of the business is busier than another, employees with transferable skills may be able to move across, either temporarily or permanently. It may also be possible to restructure by redefining existing roles rather than removing them. Agree any significant changes in writing with the employees concerned, and give redeployed staff the training they need for their new role.
4. Job sharing
Ask for volunteers who would be willing to share a role. In a job share, two people split the hours and duties of one full-time job, each on a part-time contract.
5. Unpaid leave, career breaks and secondments
Unpaid sabbaticals and career breaks can reduce wage costs for a period while keeping valued staff, who may welcome the chance to study, travel or volunteer. Secondments to a client or another part of the business can also broaden an employee’s skills and strengthen client relationships. Record the terms, including the right to return, in writing.
6. Reduced hours or days
Some employees may be happy to reduce their hours or days, and you can invite flexible working requests. You may also propose a temporary or permanent reduction in hours for a group of staff. Unless the contract contains a clear lay-off or short-time working clause, you will need the employees’ agreement, otherwise you risk claims for breach of contract or constructive dismissal.
New restrictions on fire and rehire, now expected to take effect in March 2027, will mean that dismissing employees for refusing certain changes to their terms, such as cuts to pay or hours, is normally automatically unfair. Changes to terms should be agreed rather than imposed.
7. Voluntary early retirement
Offering early retirement on a voluntary basis can create vacancies for people who would otherwise be at risk. There is no default retirement age, so retirement must be the employee’s choice. Make offers carefully and consistently to avoid age discrimination, and record the terms properly, often in a settlement agreement.
8. Save money elsewhere
Before making compulsory redundancies, look closely at other costs. Can spending on entertainment or travel be reduced? Can supplier contracts be renegotiated? Are there other overheads that could be trimmed?
9. Let staff buy extra annual leave
Giving employees the option of extra holiday in return for a pro rata reduction in salary can save money when business is quiet. Set out the arrangement in writing, and make sure it does not take anyone’s pay below the National Minimum Wage.
10. Voluntary redundancy
Inviting volunteers can reduce or remove the need for compulsory redundancies. You do not have to accept every application, and volunteers are still being made redundant, so those with two years’ service are entitled to statutory redundancy pay. Our article on voluntary redundancy explains how it works.
If redundancies cannot be avoided
Whichever options you choose, follow a careful process and document any agreements properly. If the savings you need are still not achieved, compulsory redundancies may become necessary. A fair process means genuine consultation, fair redundancy selection criteria and consideration of suitable alternative roles.
If you propose to make 20 or more employees redundant at one establishment within 90 days, collective consultation rules apply. Since 6 April 2026, the maximum protective award for failing to consult collectively has doubled from 90 to 180 days’ pay per employee. Our employment solicitors can help you with restructuring a business and with wider employment law advice for employers.
To talk through the options for your business, book a free 30-minute consultation or call 0141 471 9166.
Get in touch
You are one step closer to solving it
We are here to help. Relax, you are in good hands. Book a free 30-minute consultation and an employment solicitor will explain your options in plain English, with no obligation to continue.

