
A fair and lawful redundancy process depends on choosing the right selection criteria and applying them properly. This guide for employers explains how to set a selection pool, choose and score fair criteria, and reduce the risk of unfair dismissal and discrimination claims.
When does redundancy selection apply?
Redundancy is one of the potentially fair reasons for dismissal, but only where there is a genuine redundancy situation. In law, that means the business or a workplace is closing, or the need for employees to carry out work of a particular kind has stopped or reduced.
This can happen after a restructure, a downturn in work or the introduction of new technology. Before you get to selection, you should also consider alternatives to redundancy, such as reducing overtime or pausing recruitment.
Identifying the selection pool
The selection pool is the group of employees at risk of redundancy, and it is the group your selection criteria will be applied to. Employers have a fair degree of discretion here, but a tribunal will look at whether you genuinely considered who should be in the pool and whether your choice was reasonable.
Where particular roles are disappearing, the pool should not automatically be limited to the people currently in those roles. You should think about including employees who do the same or similar work, including in other departments or at other sites, and those whose work is interchangeable.
If the whole business is closing and there are no other sites, there is no need for a pool. A pool of one may also be fair where a role is genuinely unique, but you should still be able to explain why no one else was included.
Choosing fair selection criteria
You have reasonable freedom to choose your criteria, but you should not depart from any written redundancy procedure without a good reason, and you should follow any selection procedure agreed with a recognised trade union.
Wherever possible, use objective criteria that can be measured and checked, rather than subjective views that are hard to evidence. Common fair criteria include:
- performance or standard of work
- skills, qualifications and experience
- attendance and disciplinary records
This is not a complete list. Using a mix of criteria helps you keep the employees with the skills and experience the business needs for the future.
Applying the selection criteria
Everyone in the pool must be assessed fairly and consistently, and as far as possible on the basis of objective evidence. Scoring each employee against the agreed criteria reduces the risk of relying too heavily on one factor. You can also weight the criteria so that those most important to the future of the business carry more points.
Selection does not have to be a pure box-ticking exercise, and some judgement is often unavoidable. Where judgement is used, back it up with evidence, for example by supporting performance figures with appraisals. Keep written evidence for each score so that employees can understand how they were assessed.
Using a selection matrix
A redundancy selection matrix sets out the criteria you will use, such as skills, appraisal results and disciplinary record, and the weighting for each. Each employee in the pool is scored against every criterion, and those with the lowest total scores are provisionally selected. A clear matrix makes the decision-making process transparent, helps you apply the criteria consistently and makes challenges less likely.
What happens if selection is unfair?
If your criteria or the way you apply them are unfair or discriminatory, the dismissal may be unfair even where the redundancy is genuine. Employees with two years’ service can currently claim unfair dismissal.
From 1 January 2027, the Employment Rights Act 2025 reduces this qualifying period to six months and removes the statutory cap on the compensatory award, so the financial risk of a poor process will increase. Discrimination claims need no qualifying service and compensation is uncapped.
Selection is only one part of a fair process. You must also consult individually with the employees affected and look for suitable alternative roles.
If you propose 20 or more redundancies at one establishment within 90 days, collective consultation rules apply, and since 6 April 2026 the maximum protective award for failing to consult has doubled from 90 to 180 days’ pay. Our guide to establishing a fair reason for redundancy covers these steps in more detail.
Avoiding discrimination
You must not discriminate when selecting for redundancy. The Equality Act 2010 protects nine characteristics: age, disability, gender reassignment, marriage and civil partnership, pregnancy and maternity, race, religion or belief, sex and sexual orientation. Selecting someone because of a protected characteristic is unlawful discrimination, and selection connected with pregnancy or maternity leave is also automatically unfair dismissal.
It is also automatically unfair to select an employee for redundancy for certain other reasons, including:
- taking or asking to take family leave, such as maternity, paternity, adoption, shared parental or parental leave, or time off for dependants
- being a trade union member or not being one, or acting as a union or employee representative
- working part time or on a fixed-term contract
- asserting statutory rights, such as the National Minimum Wage, holiday pay, rest breaks or the right to opt out of the 48-hour week
- blowing the whistle or raising health and safety concerns
Even objective criteria need care. If you use attendance records, exclude absences related to pregnancy, maternity and other family leave, and consider whether disability-related absence should be discounted as a reasonable adjustment. Since 6 April 2024, employees who are pregnant, on maternity, adoption or shared parental leave, or recently returned, also have priority for any suitable alternative vacancy.
Can length of service be used?
Many employers used to rely on last in, first out, selecting the people with the shortest service first. On its own, this method is now rarely appropriate, because it can indirectly discriminate against younger workers, who tend to have shorter service.
Under the Equality Act 2010, indirect discrimination happens when an employer applies a provision, criterion or practice to everyone, but it puts people who share a protected characteristic at a particular disadvantage, and the employer cannot show it is a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim.
To use length of service, you would need to justify it in this way, for example as a means of rewarding loyalty or keeping a stable workforce.
In practice, length of service is safest as one criterion among several, given no more weight than the others, or as a tie-breaker where two employees have the same overall score.
Tips for a fair redundancy selection process
- Use objective, measurable criteria wherever possible so that employees are assessed on evidence rather than opinion.
- Where you use qualitative criteria, make sure the assessor knows the employee’s work directly and records written evidence for each score.
- Consult employee or trade union representatives on the proposed criteria before you finalise them. Agreed criteria are much easier to defend.
- Only rely on performance or disciplinary records if appraisals and rules have been applied consistently across the pool. Use a fair reference period and ignore warnings that have expired.
- If you ask employees to apply for roles in a new structure, use objective criteria in the interviews too.
- Share individual scores with affected employees, give them a chance to comment and offer an appeal.
- Record your criteria, how you applied them and the evidence behind each decision.
Some employers ask for volunteers before making compulsory redundancies, and our article on voluntary redundancy explains how this works. Where an exit is agreed, a properly drafted settlement agreement can reduce the risk of a later claim.
Frequently asked questions
What are redundancy selection criteria?
They are the factors used to decide who is selected from the pool. It is usually better to use criteria based on evidence rather than subjective judgement, such as performance, skills, qualifications, experience, attendance and disciplinary record.
Can length of service be taken into account?
Yes, but because it can disadvantage younger employees, it should normally be one criterion among several or a tie-breaker, and you should be able to justify using it.
What is a redundancy selection matrix?
It is a scoring table setting out the criteria and their weighting. Each employee in the pool is scored against each criterion, and the lowest scorers are provisionally selected, subject to consultation.
When can someone be made redundant?
Only in a genuine redundancy situation: when the business or workplace closes, or when the need for employees to do work of a particular kind stops or reduces, for example because of new technology or a restructure to cut costs.
Our employment solicitors advise employers on every stage of restructuring a business, including fair selection. To discuss your plans, book a free 30-minute consultation or call 0141 471 9166.
Get in touch
You are one step closer to solving it
We are here to help. Relax, you are in good hands. Book a free 30-minute consultation and an employment solicitor will explain your options in plain English, with no obligation to continue.






