
Dismissing an employee is never easy, whether you are the employer or the employee. Sometimes, when other options have been tried and a proper procedure has been followed, dismissal is the only realistic outcome.
But the law only treats certain reasons as potentially fair, and even then the employer must act reasonably. This guide explains the five potentially fair reasons for dismissal and how employers can reduce the risk of a claim.
Fair and unfair dismissal
An employment tribunal will look at two main questions in an unfair dismissal claim: did the employer have a potentially fair reason for the dismissal, and did it act reasonably in treating that reason as sufficient to dismiss, including by following a fair procedure? Employers should have clear disciplinary and capability policies so that employees know what is expected of them.
At present, employees normally need two years’ continuous service to bring an ordinary unfair dismissal claim. From 1 January 2027, the Employment Rights Act 2025 reduces this qualifying period to six months and removes the statutory cap on unfair dismissal compensation, so fair procedures will matter for far more employees.
Even employees with very short service can bring some claims, including claims for automatically unfair dismissal (for example, for whistleblowing or because of pregnancy), discrimination and wrongful dismissal, which is a breach of contract claim, usually about notice pay.
The five potentially fair reasons for dismissal
1. Conduct
Conduct dismissals relate to the employee’s behaviour. Your policies and rules should make clear what counts as misconduct. Common examples include repeated lateness, unauthorised absence and refusing reasonable instructions.
Gross misconduct is behaviour so serious that it destroys the relationship of trust between employer and employee, such as theft, fraud, violence or serious negligence. A single act of gross misconduct can justify dismissal without notice or pay in lieu of notice, which is known as summary dismissal, as long as a fair procedure has been followed.
For less serious misconduct, an employee will usually receive one or more warnings before dismissal and will be entitled to notice or pay in lieu of notice. Our article on dismissal where the conduct is not gross misconduct looks at this in more detail.
Conduct outside work can also justify dismissal where it affects the employee’s ability to do their job or harms the employer’s reputation. Misuse of social media is a common example.
2. Capability or performance
Capability covers both poor performance and ill health. Before dismissing for poor performance, an employer should normally follow a fair procedure. That usually means explaining the concerns, setting clear and realistic targets, offering support or training, reviewing progress regularly and giving warnings before reaching a decision. Our performance management advice can help you get this right.
Where the issue is ill health, the employer should consult the employee, obtain up-to-date medical evidence, often through occupational health or the employee’s GP, and consider reasonable adjustments or alternative roles before deciding whether to dismiss.
Where the employee is disabled, the duty to make reasonable adjustments and the risk of a disability discrimination claim must also be considered. Our absence management service covers long-term and frequent short-term absence. You can read more about the difference between the two in our article on conduct and capability dismissals.
3. Redundancy
Redundancy is a potentially fair reason where a business closes, a workplace closes or the need for employees to do work of a particular kind reduces. The employer must act fairly throughout, including by consulting, using fair selection criteria and considering suitable alternative work. Some redundancy dismissals are automatically unfair, for example where an employee is selected because she is pregnant.
4. Breach of a statutory restriction
A dismissal can be fair where continuing to employ someone would break the law. Examples include:
- the employee no longer has the right to work in the UK
- the employee must drive for their job but has lost their driving licence
- the employee no longer holds a qualification or registration that the law requires for the role
Even in these situations, the employer should still follow a fair process and consider whether there is any alternative role.
5. Some other substantial reason
Some other substantial reason, often shortened to SOSR, covers reasons that do not fit into the other categories but are still substantial enough to justify dismissal. Examples can include an irretrievable breakdown in working relationships, or pressure from an important client that will not work with the employee. Each case depends on its facts, and the employer must still act reasonably.
Following a fair dismissal procedure
Whatever the reason, employers should act consistently and reasonably. Where possible, try to resolve issues informally first. For disciplinary and performance matters, follow the Acas Code of Practice on disciplinary and grievance procedures, which means:
- establishing the facts through a reasonable investigation
- telling the employee about the problem in writing and providing the evidence
- holding a meeting to discuss the problem
- allowing the employee to be accompanied by a colleague or trade union representative
- deciding on appropriate action and confirming it in writing
- giving the employee the chance to appeal
Tribunals take the Code into account, and if an employer unreasonably fails to follow it, compensation can be increased by up to 25 per cent. Our step-by-step guide to terminating an employee sets out the practical stages.
Notice and contractual issues
When you dismiss an employee, you must give the notice set out in their contract, or the statutory minimum if that is longer. The statutory minimum is one week for each complete year of service, up to 12 weeks. The exception is a dismissal for gross misconduct or another serious breach of contract by the employee, where you may be able to dismiss without notice.
If you dismiss in breach of contract, for example without proper notice when the employee has not committed gross misconduct, you may lose the benefit of post-termination restrictions in the contract. Our restrictive covenants page explains how to protect your business.
Reducing the risk of a discrimination claim
Make sure that no protected characteristic, such as disability, sex, race, age or pregnancy, plays any part in the decision to dismiss or in how the process is run. Following a fair procedure, applying policies consistently and keeping clear records of the reasons for your decision will help you show that the dismissal was not discriminatory.
Do you have to give written reasons for a dismissal?
Employees with at least two years’ service are entitled to ask for a written statement of the reasons for their dismissal, and the employer must provide it within 14 days.
An employee who is dismissed while pregnant, or during maternity or adoption leave, is entitled to written reasons automatically, whatever their length of service. Even where there is no legal requirement, it is good practice to confirm the reasons for a dismissal in writing.
If you are considering dismissing an employee and want to make sure you have a fair reason and a fair process, our advice for employers can help. Book a free 30-minute consultation or call 0141 471 9166.
Get in touch
You are one step closer to solving it
We are here to help. Relax, you are in good hands. Book a free 30-minute consultation and an employment solicitor will explain your options in plain English, with no obligation to continue.






